Observations on Relevant Commercial Media

July 26, 2006

Very Interesting Research – JupiterResearch: Display vs. Search Advertising

Filed under: , , — Sean Ammirati @ 9:36 pm

Media Post’s Blog - http://blogs.mediapost.com/online_minute/?p=1301 – has coverage on a new JupiterResearch report claiming that the percentage of online advertising allocated to search will grow versus display advertising in the next 5 years.

As I see it, the biggest advantage to search advertising over display is the ability for the advertising to be targetted to a user’s intentions (based on the keywords entered.)

However, I find it hard to believe over the next 5 years there won’t be other technologies that allow other ads to also be targeted based on user’s intentions. Examples of this include behavioral targeting and obviously our next generation approach being introduced at mSpoke.

If these technologies are equally as good at understanding & targeting advertisements based on a user’s intentions I find it hard to believe the trend won’t shift the other way toward display advertising. What do you think?

Google: Cost Per Order vs. Cost Per Click?

Filed under: , — Sean Ammirati @ 8:19 am

Even with my negative post last night on Google, I should point out that I do have a tremendous amount of respect for the firm and what they are doing to lead generation (as one component of advertising and the one that search engine marketing does best.)

Om Malik has a post on GigaOM - http://gigaom.com/2006/07/25/field-notes-from-the-googleplex/ - about his recent trip to GooglePlex & interactions with a number of different employees.

The last interaction he describes is with Benjamin Ling, who is responsible for Google Checkout. Om reports,

He explained that if you spend $1,000 on the Google ad network, Google Checkout would process $10,000 worth of transactions for free. The more you spend on ads, the more transaction fee savings you get. “It will hyper accelerate our system,” he said. And with a twinkle in his eye, he said, “We make all our money on advertising.”

This is huge, what Google is good at is generating leads! With this new capability, there seems to be no doubt, they’ll track the purchase to the end of the system and truly know what those leads are worth. If they know this, they may eventually charge a cost per order instead of cost per click. (Based on Benjamin’s comments it looks like they want 10% of revenue for the lead – based on the ratio of $1k spent for $10k of transaction)

My Work is Play to Me Too

Filed under: — Sean Ammirati @ 7:56 am

Brad Feld has a great post up title “My Work is Play to Me” I really resonated with it. When I joined Arthur Andersen in the summer of 1999, they had a lot of discussion about “work life balance.” They tried to convince us that we’d have this balance between work & play time and that if you “worked hard you could play hard too.”

What I’ve found since then, is that when I’m working hard and creating something, it feels like playing! Brad does a great job explaining this … …

http://www.feld.com/blog/archives/001864.html

Advertising on Social Networks

Filed under: , , — Sean Ammirati @ 7:48 am

There was a very interesting panel at ad:tech investigating advertising on social networking sites.  Here is iMedia Connection’s Coverage -http://www.imediaconnection.com/content/10585.asp

It certainly will be interesting to see how this plays out.  My instinct is there is a great way to monetize these sites, but the advertising targeting will need to evolve.  I think I know just the company to help.

July 25, 2006

Fear of Google - Show me the data?

Filed under: , , — Sean Ammirati @ 11:49 pm

Having explained mSpoke’s vision repeatedly with a number of potential partners, customers & investors over the last year – there is a pattern that you’d have to be trying to miss at this point … The Google objection!

While it is phrased slightly differently in each setting, the basic question ranges from “Why wont Google do ________?” or “How will Google react to _____?” or “Is Google doing _____?”

I should state up front that I have a tremendous amount of respect for Google and the company & revenue that they have built. However, I find it amazing & misguided that there is a pretty constant fear of Google out innovating everyone.

I find this amazing, because there dominance is really in the search space and not any of the other properties they have launched. I find it misguided, because I believe there will always be value to be created at the edges of industry by entrepreneurs like myself.

I became more comfortable with this belief a few days ago when Bill Tancer from Hitwise updated his post on the top Google Properties from May. Here is a link to the updated data:http://weblogs.hitwise.com/bill-tancer/2006/07/google_properties_updated.html

What jumped to mind is that almost 90% of the traffic on their properties comes from search (combining the 80% on standard Google search & 9% on image search.) The next 9% of traffic is then made up by next 4 most popular properties:

  • Google Mail
  • Google News
  • Google Maps
  • Blogger

In addition to the singular nature of the majority of their traffic, it also becomes interesting to look at how little fruit (in terms of share of overall traffic) has resulted from the 20% of energy employees spend working on new projects.

As Bill points out in his analysis,

“there has been minimal movement since I published this table in May. What you may notice is the absence of Google’s new domain’s: Checkout, Calendar and Spreadsheet which were all below the top 20 during this time frame” [The 20th most popular Google Property was Google – Local with 0.03% of overall traffic]

To take it one step further, it is really interesting to look at the top 98% of traffic coming from 6 site and see when they were launched or acquired into the Google Network:

Property

Year Launched

Google

1998

Google Image Search

2001

Google Mail

2004

Google News

2002

Google Maps

2005

Blogger

2003 (acquisition)

To be fair, a significant portion of their impressive revenue actually comes from 3rd party sites not leveraging their properties at all, but just integrated their CPC ads through AdSense http://www.internetnews.com/bus-news/article.php/3621581

However, as an entrepreneur sometimes it was refreshing to take a fresh look at the data and gain a little more confidence in the ability for all of us to compete & add value in the marketplace.

July 24, 2006

Two Amazing RSS Statistics

Filed under: , — Sean Ammirati @ 5:47 pm

I was doing some research today on RSS growth in the publishing market and came across two complimentary data points.  The information is not brand new, but was really interesting to me.

First, according to Nielsen//NetRatings (Sept 2005) …

RSS users are significantly more engaged in online news than non-users, visiting an average of 10.6 news sites compared with 3.4 news sites for non-users
http://www.prnewswire.com/cgi-bin/stories.pl?ACCT=104&STORY=/www/story/09-20-2005/0004111250

If this is correct, then publishers should really begin to spend heavily on improving their RSS feeds.  Luckily, I quickly found a recent (May 2006) report from JupiterResearch that claims …

48 percent of current RSS publishers are spending $250,000 or more to deploy and manage syndicated content
http://biz.yahoo.com/bw/060515/20060515005658.html?.v=1

If you are a content publishers today who are not developing a coherent & long-term RSS strategy, consider this your wakeup call.

July 21, 2006

Leaving it on the Field

Filed under: , — Sean Ammirati @ 10:47 pm

I grew up playing a lot of soccer. For one month every four years when the world cup is on, I become a sports fanatic and soccer comes back to the top of my mind.

After this most recent tournament, I personally have found myself reflecting a lot that Totti’s goal against Australia occurred in penalty time with seconds left. Had Totti & his team mates just given up at the 92nd minute, they would not have gotten the penalty kick and won the game…

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S5uMInOylsU

… ultimately leading to winning the tournament.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=19S30VNn5lo

This has gotten me thinking a lot about a phrase one of my coaches used to say all the time - ‘leave it on the field.’ While I certainly have heard this in a lot of sports, it seems a particularly appropriate analogy to soccer. In soccer with the concept of penalty time, ultimately you have some idea how close you are to running out of time – but as Totti showed the world you just have to play until the match / period is over. Because you never know when you’re going to get a break that ultimately can lead to becoming a champion.

After reflecting on this regularly over the last few weeks … the one thing I want my colleagues to say about me whether ultimately mSpoke succeeds or not is that I left it on the field.

July 20, 2006

Making Participation Part of My Day

Filed under: , — Sean Ammirati @ 1:49 pm

Over the last few months I have become a more & more prolific reader of RSS feeds.  The Newsgator Mobile on my Motorola Q has made this easier than ever.

What I find difficult is that I’m not doing a good job participating in the conversation.  I read, but don’t comment.  I read, but don’t use del.icio.us.  I read, but don’t blog.

Ironically, it has become more & more obvious that this is key.  Fred & Brad at Union Square have taken this to a new level by publically recruiting their next analyst – a replacement from Charlie O’Donnell.

http://www.unionsquareventures.com/2006/07/looking_for_the.html

I have met Charlie & I can assure you that person will have huge shoes to fill.  It will be interesting to see how their experiment goes.

I’m curious what disciplines people have put in place to do this better.  If nothing else, this is a public declaration that I’m going to try and participate better.  (Hopefully that is the motivation that I need.)

Any tips from my readers?  (If I have any, after a 2 month break from posting.)